Originally Posted by SD-[Inc]
Lizzy's was much better IMO. Johnny's does have a nice headshot multiplier though.
It might have been a decent legendary about midway in the game or a very strong one early on. But by the time you get it, pretty much any pistol you can find off a random baddie is better than his gun. It's a shame because the gun looks really cool and has a neat melee attack, but it's stats are terrible.